Developing skills through training is critical, especially in the realm of project management, where a small knowledge gap can lead to big project failures. However, effective training is not just about conveying information; it’s about ensuring that learning translates to improved job performance and tangible results. This is where Kirkpatrick’s Model of Training Evaluation comes in. In this post, we’ll explore how Kirkpatrick’s four levels can be applied to a project management training program, shedding light on why a structured evaluation approach is essential for maximizing training impact.
Level One: Reaction
Measures how participants feel about the training experience, their immediate impressions, satisfaction, and perceived value.
Why It Matters for Project Management Training:
Project management training can be intense, with detailed concepts about scope, risks, budgets, and timelines. If participants find the content irrelevant or the delivery method dull, they might disengage and fail to absorb the material.
How To Measure:
- Feedback Surveys: After each training session, distribute a brief survey or questionnaire asking about the relevance of topics covered, the instructor’s effectiveness, and overall satisfaction.
- Instant Polls or NPS (Net Promoter Score): Gauge how likely participants are to recommend the training to others.
Example:
Imagine a three-day in-person project management fundamentals course. At the end of Day 1, you ask participants to rate the trainer’s clarity, course pacing, and how confident they feel about applying new knowledge. High satisfaction levels might suggest that you’re on the right track; low or lukewarm feedback can signal the need to adjust course content or teaching style.
Level Two: Learning
Evaluates the degree to which participants acquired the intended knowledge, skills, and attitudes during the training.
Why It Matters for Project Management Training:
Without a measurable increase in knowledge or skills, a training program loses its impact. Project managers need a firm grasp of methodologies (e.g., waterfall vs. agile), tools (e.g., Gantt charts, project management software), and soft skills (e.g., stakeholder communication).
How To Measure:
- Pre- and Post-Training Tests: Compare knowledge levels before and after the training via quizzes or scenario-based assessments.
- Practical Exercises and Simulations: Ask participants to create a project schedule, identify risks, or manage a simulated project environment.
Example:
Before starting the training, each participant completes a short quiz on basic project management terminology. On the last day, they retake a similar quiz with more in-depth questions to assess knowledge gains. If the average score jumps from 60% to 85%, you have a clear indicator that learning took place.
Level Three: Behavior
Determines whether participants are applying the skills and knowledge learned in training back on the job.
Why It Matters for Project Management Training:
A project manager’s effectiveness is mostly visible in daily tasks: planning projects, leading meetings, managing risks, and communicating with stakeholders. Even if participants ace the final test, their newly acquired skills need to be observed in real project environments.
How To Measure:
- Observations and Performance Reviews: Managers or mentors track whether the trained project managers are using scheduling tools effectively, updating risk registers, and communicating proactively.
- 360° Feedback: Collect input from team members, peers, and supervisors regarding any visible improvement in project leadership and collaboration.
Example:
Consider a company that introduced a structured risk management approach during training. Two months after the program, you can check if each participant is proactively identifying and documenting risks in a shared repository and whether risk mitigations are tracked consistently. If participants are consistently practicing new skills on actual projects, you’ll see behavior change in action.
Level Four: Results
Assesses the overall impact of the training on organizational metrics. This can include productivity, profitability, quality improvements, or customer satisfaction scores.
Why It Matters for Project Management Training:
Project management plays a direct role in delivering on-time, on-budget, and high-quality results. Training investments should translate into tangible improvements, like reduced cost overruns or faster time-to-market.
How To Measure:
- Project Performance Metrics: Compare pre- and post-training data on schedule adherence, cost variance, and project success rates.
- ROI Analysis (Phillips Model Extension): Calculate the financial return of the training by looking at cost savings and revenue growth attributed to better project execution.
Example:
After investing in a training program aimed at enhancing scheduling and budgeting skills, an organization might see a 20% reduction in project cost overruns. This not only indicates improved project efficiency but also a potential high return on the training investment.
Why Kirkpatrick’s Model Is So Powerful
- Structured & Comprehensive: By progressing from basic feedback (Level One) to actual business impact (Level Four), the model paints a complete picture of training success.
- Actionable Insights: Each level suggests specific measures (e.g., quizzes, feedback forms, on-the-job observations) that can help refine the training program or prove its ROI.
- Adaptable to Different Training Types: Whether you’re focusing on project management fundamentals or advanced leadership skills, you can easily adapt the metrics and tools to fit your learning objectives.
Getting Started with Kirkpatrick’s Model
- Set Clear Objectives: Define what you want trainees to learn (theory, best practices, tools) and how it should improve the organization.
- Design Targeted Measurements: Align your questions, quizzes, and observation criteria with those objectives.
- Implement a Feedback Loop: Regularly review and act on feedback to improve training content and delivery in real time.
- Link Results to Business Goals: Ensure that the changes in behavior (Level Three) and results (Level Four) are measured against KPIs that matter—such as project success rate, cost savings, or customer satisfaction.
Evaluating project management training through the lens of Kirkpatrick’s Model brings clarity and accountability to your learning initiatives. By stepping through each level from participant reactions and knowledge acquisition to on-the-job behavior and measurable results, you’ll gain a deeper understanding of the true impact of your training. Ultimately, a well-executed evaluation not only helps justify training investments but also guides continuous improvement, ensuring that project managers are truly equipped to drive success in an ever-evolving landscape.
Want to Know More About Our Training Programs?
Have a look here to discover all offerings. Or feel free to contact us for a more in-depth discussion.